★★★☆☆

I'll start by saying that I'm going to list the things I didn't like
about this book, but I still enjoyed reading it. I did like the main
character and I looked forward to sitting down with it each evening.
Frankly, I don't usually complain about the occasional grammar error,
but some of the other issues had me flipping back to fact check and that
bothers me. If it had been better edited, I would have given it 4
stars.
I dislike when books switch between the first and third
person. I really don't think the story was better served by this
technique. Also, the tense is fairly inconsistent, most especially in
the first person POV.
There are a few sections where Dani Mueller is speaking to her German parents. The author has the parents
speak in German while Dani responds in English. The end result? You are
almost given the mistaken impression that two different languages are
being used, which begs the question if the parents speak English
(because it appears as though they understand her when the conversation
is written in two different languages), why wouldn't they speak it to
her - or even more puzzling, why would Dani not speak their native
language when addressing them? I believe it was done to add flavor, but
those with a rudimentary knowledge of German will end up reading the
same conversation twice, and even if the reader doesn't understand,
Dani's responses (which reword what the parents said for those who
didn't understand it) sound totally unrealistic for normal speech. For
example, if the parents ask 'why didn't you tell us' her response would
be 'I didn't tell you because ...' and every one of her responses has to
be worded similarly. I think it would have been more effective to
simply let the reader know the conversation was occurring in German and
write it in English.
Possible spoilers:
I found some of
the later scenarios a little implausible. The first 70% of the book was
enjoyable, but the main character went a little 'off the reservation'
toward the end. I understand there was motivation with regard to his
daughter, but doing certain things which were at the least unethical and
even some that were illegal in order to make a case seemed too far to
me.
The mother-in-law that hated him and was trying to destroy
his life was a bit overdone, too. Perhaps, if there had been some sort
of prologue, maybe a scene at Scarsdale's wife's funeral wherein the MIL
displayed irrational behavior, I would have found it more acceptable,
but it seemed to come out of left field just to add more strife to
Scarsdale's already stressful life.
Another character was
supposed to have been paroled after spending six years in prison, but
then is said to have been in court watching his brother's trial - an
event that had only occurred two and a half years earlier. I think overall, the timeline was perhaps a little too short for some of the events that occurred.
Having said all of that, though, I truly enjoyed reading the book and I think
this author is off to a great start. I look forward to reading future
works by him.